Address by Secretary(ER) on Ensuring India's Energy Security

  09/03/2009  

Address by Sh. H.S. Puri, Secretary(ER), Ministry of External Affairs on Ensuring India's Energy Security:
Domestic Measures and External Policy Approaches
9 March 2009

Dr. Bhartia
Dr. Parekh,
Mr. Banerjee
Ladies and Gentlemen,

Thank you for inviting me to address the National Conference on “Ensuring India’s Energy Security: Domestic Measures and External Policy Approaches.” It stands to reason that when there is a Guest of Honour, it should not be necessary for others to address the same session. But, since I am here, let me say a few words.

2. Twenty First century global realities have altered the concept of national security. While national security is a holistic concept, energy security is one of its major components. The latter essentially involves ensuring uninterrupted supply of energy to support the economic and commercial activities necessary for sustained economic growth.

3. Energy consumption is both a necessary condition for economic growth and a consequence of it. Need of the hour, therefore, is to acknowledge the important challenges to India’s energy security, which are both internal and external in nature. Internally, India has a limited resource base and lacks adequate infrastructure. The external challenge lies in getting a continuous supply of energy at reasonable prices as domestic production is low but the demand is high.

4. In a 2004 report, the International Energy Agency (IEA) estimated that by 2030 the world would be consuming around 121 million barrels per day and, to achieve this, the global oil industry requires an investment of approximately $3 trillion. In a 2006 report, the agency revised the estimated investment volume upwards to $4.3 trillion to produce a little less quantum of oil, 116 million barrels per day, by 2030. This rise of 43% in investment volume to produce 5 million barrels less per day for the same period has been attributed to the end of ‘cheap oil era’. This in turn is a result of the ageing existing “giant and super giant” oil fields as well as the need to drill for oil in new and small sized wells, whose marginal cost would be much higher than that of existing giant and super giant fields.

5. The recent drop in crude oil prices from a peak of US $147 a barrel to below $40 has evidently provided relief to oil importing countries such as India, which have been triply inflicted by huge oil pool deficits, growing food prices and global economic downturn. But based on current oil market fundamentals and past experience, there is no reason to believe that the current fall in oil prices is indicative of any future trend. Sooner or later prices will rise.

6. According to the Integrated Energy Policy India needs to sustain an economic growth rate of 8-10% over the next 25 years, in order to eradicate poverty and meet its human development needs. This would require augmentation of primary energy supplies by 4-5 times by 2030-31. At present, India consumes approximately 3.1 million barrels of oil a day and this is expected to grow to a couple of million barrels more, making India the third largest consuming country in Asia and the fourth largest in the world. Expenditure-wise, year-on-year basis, a rise in the price of oil by a single dollar costs the economy approximately Rs.17.7 million. Besides, it would trigger oil-induced cascading effects, including inflation, unemployment, and social unrest.

7. India aspires to a medium-to-long term strategy of implementing a strategic shift from fossil fuels to non-fossil fuels, from non-renewable to renewable sources of energy, and from conventional to non-conventional sources of energy. Our energy mix currently is 51% based on coal, 36% on oil, 9% on natural gas and only 2% from hydropower and nuclear energy respectively. It is estimated that by 2030-31, we would have to import 66% of our coal, 90% of our oil and 60% of our natural gas. Presently, we depend to the extent of 70% on imported oil which makes us vulnerable to external shocks.

8. Ensuring continuous availability of commercial energy at competitive prices to support economic growth and meet our energy needs with safe, clean and convenient forms of energy is vital for the continued growth of the economy. We need to adopt a multi-pronged and coordinated energy strategy which requires: increasing the domestic supply of crude oil and gas by fast-tracking upstream activities; substituting oil consumption by gas and clean coal (keeping in view the relative energy yields in dollar terms of various fuel options); increasing reliance on renewable sources of energy such as nuclear energy, solar energy, wind energy and bio-fuels; increasing our own hydro-electricity production and developing mutually beneficial models to tap the hydro-electricity potential in neighboring countries; improving energy efficiency; diversifying our supply sources and acquiring energy assets abroad.

9. Let me elaborate on some of the key elements of our energy security today:

i. The Government has been trying to increase domestic exploration and production with efforts aimed at encouraging investment in the exploration of hydrocarbons, development of fields and production and marketing, strengthening of National Oil Companies and improved recovery of domestic hydrocarbon resources.

ii. Diversification of sources of oil and gas supply is the key to the promotion of our energy security. While maintaining our traditional supply lines from the Middle East, we must augment our energy supplies from countries in Africa, Latin America and South-East Asia. In 2007-08, India actually sourced nearly 18% of its oil from Africa. We are also seriously looking at the CIS region for oil, natural gas, hydropower and uranium resources. Latin America is another attractive energy supply source for India. In South Asia, a network of gas pipelines and power grids will enhance energy security in the region, essentially of India, and also significantly benefit its smaller neighbors, reduce cost of fuel transportation and help in an optimal and efficient harnessing of energy resources.

iii. Obtaining equity oil and gas abroad would also help in augmenting our energy reserves. Since the early 1980s, Indian oil companies both public and private have been investing in overseas oil and gas projects, with activities covering 20 countries today. OVL’s total equity oil production is currently around 9 million tones a year.

iv. Creation of a Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR), though expensive to create and maintain, would reduce the country’s vulnerability to short-term oil shocks and soothe price fluctuations. Apart from the creation of SPR, co-operation with other Asian countries, which maintain strategic reserves, is required. For instance, mutually beneficial co-operation with Japan, South Korea, Taiwan and Singapore is possible in areas such as joint identification and storage of reserves at low-cost locations, co-coordinated response to global and regional energy crisis and short-term lending and borrowing facility in the event of temporary shortage.

v. India has promising potential of renewables, nuclear energy and non-conventional hydrocarbon resources such as Gas Hydrates and Shale Oil. Exploitation of these resources would require development of appropriate technologies through indigenous R&D, involvement of global energy majors and creation of a sound regulatory and policy framework to encourage investment in these sources of energy.

vi. On the renewable energy front, India has a strong manufacturing and R&D orientation and is emerging as a hub of wind, solar, biomass related manufacturing and exports. Over 11,200 MW of renewable based capacity has already been installed. Numerous fiscal and financial incentives are being given for the promotion and exploitation of renewable energy.

vii. Nuclear energy is another potential source to ensure India’s energy security in the medium and long term. Nuclear power development is essential not only in the context of energy security but also in terms of its environmental advantages. With the Indo-US nuclear cooperation agreement we can hope to secure the required supplies of nuclear fuel for enhancing our nuclear power generation.

viii. Improving energy efficiency through technology and innovative approaches constitutes an important aspect of our multi-pronged strategy. Increasing energy efficiency can lead to reducing energy requirement for the same level of economic output.

10. As part of its growing emphasis on energy security, a new Energy Security Division has been created in the MEA to facilitate our multifaceted global engagement in pursuit of India’s interests in the energy sector.

11. I believe that the current economic downturn provides both oil producing countries and oil consuming countries a perfect opportunity to enhance cooperation on mutually agreed terms and conditions and enter into long-term contracts. Oil exporting countries faced with falling revenues are anxious to manage the volatility of oil markets and stabilize their oil incomes. According to the International Monetary Fund, a decline of $1 in the price of crude would translate into a loss in revenues of $3.5 billion for Saudi Arabia, $300 million for Qatar, $1 billion for the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and $960 million for Kuwait. The recent drop in demand has drastically reduced prices leading oil refineries to build up huge stocks, both stable and mobile. According to the Wall Street Journal, oil supplies are now building at such a rate that over 40 million barrels are being held in idle supertankers around the world. Thus, it is obvious that the present situation is opportune for both oil producing and consuming countries to enter into ‘contracts’ to hedge their losses from unforeseen shocks and spikes.

12. Ladies and Gentlemen, as we grow as a nation, our energy needs are bound to grow concurrently. With depleting reserves, energy security takes on a serious connotation. If we are to meet India’s overall growth objectives, ensuring energy security of the country is of critical importance. It is imperative that all stakeholders strive towards reducing our dependence on fossil fuels in the medium to long term by increasing the share of renewables in our overall energy mix. The challenge before us is to augment our domestic supplies while consolidating and diversifying our external resources so as to achieve a more rational and sustainable energy matrix over the next 10-15 years. We strongly support efforts to develop a cooperative framework through intensive consumer-producer dialogue, transparent exchange of data and information and cooperation in R&D in conventional and non-conventional energy resources. The current slump will not in any way dampen India’s investment thrust in the field of energy. The need of the hour is to plan ahead and secure the future of our younger generation.

13. Before I conclude, let me respond positively and enthusiastically to the suggestion made by Mr. Bhartia to establish an Energy Think Tank funded jointly by the Government and the public and private sector. This is a suggestion that has been made earlier and I can confirm that the Ministry of External Affairs would be happy to look at such a proposal.

14. I would like to congratulate CII for taking the initiative in organizing this Conference and inviting experts from various fields to discuss an important topic as Energy Security.

New Delhi
March 9,2009

Home